Newcastle United’s Summer Transfer Window Review

Newcastle United experienced several setbacks during the 2025 summer transfer window. Early in the window, the Magpies sought to sign several big-name players, but these players ultimately left for other clubs, leaving fans concerned about their club’s continued appeal despite their Champions League campaign.

The biggest blow came with Alexander Isak’s publicly announced departure, ultimately joining Liverpool for a record-breaking £125 million. As we previously reported, this transfer was a significant shock to the club and its fans.

Early Disappointment and Doubt

Isak’s departure left a void in the team and dampened morale. However, the real issue was the club’s failure to achieve its early goals. This raised questions about the Magpies’ ability to truly attract big-name players. All of this drama left a bitter taste in the air during the early stages of the transfer window.

Delayed Relief and New Hope

As the week wore on, the club picked up the pace and completed some key transfers. Anthony Elanga joined from Nottingham Forest, who showcased their attacking prowess in pace and width. Malik Thiaw, acquired from AC Milan, strengthened the defense, while Jacob Ramsey, brought in from Aston Villa, injected dynamism into the midfield. Aaron Ramsdale, loaned from Southampton, also intensified competition for the goalkeeping position.

In recent days, the team welcomed the signings of Nick Waltmades from Stuttgart and Yoann Visa from Brentford. Notably, Visa’s £55 million transfer was completed on transfer deadline day, despite our report a few weeks prior that Brentford were reluctant to part with him. Many commentators have described Waltmades as a cross between Dimitar Berbatov and Harry Kane, suggesting he could become the team’s long-term number nine.

The club spent a total of £253.6 million and sold £151.5 million, resulting in a net spend of -£102.1 million. Despite the significant investment, Isak’s departure still weighs heavily on the club.

While the additions of new faces have enhanced squad depth and quality, early setbacks and the departure of a star striker leave this transfer window somewhat incomplete. Therefore, it’s difficult to rate this transfer window higher than a 6 out of 10. We believe the club has made significant progress in the latter stages, but the loss of a player like Isak will be a long-term concern.